
When I was a kid I somehow acquired a paperback copy of Ray Bradbury’s The Illustrated Man. I was always bookish, with more time to read than new books, so I tended to re-read the ones I had. I must have read The Illustrated Man a dozen times. As I have been working with people who are struggling to get along with each other, there is one story from The Illustrated Man that keeps coming back to me: “Kaleidoscope.” I think this tale of disaster and acceptance has a deep meaning for all of us, even those of us who will never venture into space.
The story starts with a bang: an explosion that splits the ship “like a can opener,” spilling its inhabitants into space. They are all sealed in their suits, but without “force units” to maneuver, all they can do is fall “as pebbles fall down wells.” They are falling away from each other, but still in radio contact, for a time at least. The story simply relates their overlapping conversations and the thoughts of one of them, Hollis. It’s a picture of what remains after the niceties of rank are ripped away.
In other words, an answer to the question: “How do we treat each other when there are no consequences?”
The space-goers are now individual meteors, each heading in on their own course. Hollis realizes he is going to hit the Earth; others, the moon, or Jupiter, or somewhere else. Hollis is at first detached, watching his body fall as he had once watched snowflakes drift down.
“It’s a long way down,” one of the other men starts to moan, objecting that he doesn’t want to die. Hollis identifies him as Stimson and comforts him before Applegate cuts in. Hollis and Applegate had not been friends. Applegate taunts Hollis, who seethes because he can’t do anything. Another man drifts by, screaming so that none of them can hear anything else. Hollis considers the alternatives, reaches for him, and smashes his face mask. Silence.
Now they can talk again. The captain attempts to order the men to be quiet. Applegate dares the captain to make him: “Your ship was a bad ship and you were a bad captain and I hope you break when you hit the moon.” The captain orders Applegate to stop but says no more.
Applegate then tells Hollis that he put a bad word against him and is responsible for Hollis’s career stalling. Outwardly, Hollis says it doesn’t matter.
But Hollis overhears Lespere talking about the good life he’s leaving, with wives on three planets and no regrets. Hollis lashes out, telling Lespere that it’s over, as if it never happened.
“What good does it do you?” he cries to Lespere. “Now? When a thing’s over it’s not good any more. You’re no better off than me.”
“I’m resting easy,” says Lespere. “I’ve had my turn. I’m not getting mean at the end, like you.”
In response Hollis cries; he’s never been mean but now everything is coming out. And he’s comforted by another, just as he comforted Stimson at the story’s beginning.
Applegate apologizes, saying that he didn’t really get Hollis blacklisted, that he didn’t know why he said it. Stone realizes he’s joined the Myrmidone cluster of asteroids that sweeps between Mars and Earth every five years. “It’s like a big kaleidoscope,” he says, in awe of its beauty.
The men say their goodbyes as they drift out of range, even Hollis and Applegate.
Hollis reflects on “a terrible and empty life,” wishing only to do something to make up for all the meanness he’s stored inside him. He’s somewhat comforted to know that his ashes will fertilize some small corner of the earth, giving life, and wonders if anyone will see him burn up.
A small boy on an Illinois country road does. His mother reminds him to make a wish.
Story ends.
Let me share what I think this story tells us about how we treat each other. We start with a ship and a crew with all the disparities of temperament and petty resentments of any group. They function, but perhaps not well–at least not well enough to prevent the fatal explosion.
The captain, one senses, relied on his positional authority to enforce compliance rather than expertise or genuine respect. When disaster he is silent at first, unable to issue commands to undo the disaster. He does not attempt to comfort his crew, does not reach out to them. His knee-jerk response is to command Applegate to be silent, with only his authority as persuasion. He wants to take away the one thing that the crew has left, communication, because he cannot control it. He fails, and tellingly no one stands up for him.
My question for us all is, how would those we work with treat us when consequences are stripped away? I suspect that if we have cultivated trust and pride and kindness, we will find it returned. If we’ve built relationships, they will last. If we’ve been cruel and transactional, or even indifferent and transactional, we’ll find ourselves on the losing end.
For those of us who lead groups, it is worth considering how those we are responsible for might treat us if all power to discipline vanished. It doesn’t have to be anything as dramatic as what happened to Bradbury’s unnamed captain; maybe they won the lottery and are no longer financially dependent on their job, so can speak their mind; maybe you’ve suffered a reverse and no longer have power. What would they say to you?
How about how the peers treat each other? Bradbury, I think, has a great grasp of interpersonal dynamics. Hollis first comforts, then is comforted; is abused, then abuses another. It’s not whether people are inherently good or bad; it’s how they choose to show up for each other in the moment. Sometimes meanness might happen because someone is grappling with the burden of a sudden inescapable truth. If only we could all be like Lespere, secure in the memories of his good life as it ends, telling Hollis he understands and doesn’t take it personally. We would be happier.
I’m not doing bullet points because Bradbury doesn’t deserve to be reduced to that, but I would like to close by reflecting on a few things. How would we treat others if nothing constrained us? Based on how we’ve been to them in the past, how would they treat us? Would they give us gratitude? Indifference? A twist of the knife? Part of it might be where they are, but a bigger part might be how we’ve been to them.
Always loathe to give advice, I will offer some words as I drift out of range (for now at least): maybe spend some time thinking about what we’ve put out there, and whether we will meet the end like the captain, scorned and ineffectual; Stone, philosophical and fortunate; Lespere, content and peaceful; or Applegate and Hollis, angry but finally understanding. I don’t know whether it will be any comfort at the end, but I can guess that it will help make the days before we get there better for everyone.
The last lines, too, tell us something. Hollis’s last wish is to have done good in his life. Then he is seen as a shooting star by a young boy he’s never met. Perhaps that sight inspires him, changes his life? The lesson I tease there is that we can change others’ lives in ways that we will never know. And perhaps we can’t control how.
So until next time, expect the unexpected, stay informed, and I’ll stay informal.
30
